Ralph Mode - Autonomous Development Loops

Autonomous development loops with iteration, backpressure gates, and completion criteria. Use for sustained coding sessions that require multiple iterations, test validation, and structured progress tracking. Supports Next.js, Python, FastAPI, and GPU workloads with Ralph Wiggum methodology adapted for OpenClaw.

Security Scan

This is an instruction-only coordination skill for iterative/autonomous development loops; its files and runtime instructions align with that purpose and it does not request credentials, install code, or contact external endpoints.

Purpose & Capability

The name and description promise autonomous development loops; the SKILL.md, references, and loop.sh implement a project-first loop/coordination methodology (plans, gates, spawn sub-agents, run tests/linters/commits). There are no unrelated environment variables, binaries, or install steps that don't match the stated purpose.

Instruction Scope

The instructions direct agents and sub-agents to read project files (IMPLEMENTATION_PLAN.md, AGENTS.md, specs/, src/), run project validation commands (tests, lint, typecheck, build) and make commits. That is coherent with the stated purpose, but it grants the agent broad discretion over repository files and lifecycle actions (spawn sub-agents, run arbitrary project commands, update/commit plan files). Also the references mention spawning large numbers of sub-agents (e.g., 'up to 250 parallel Sonnet subagents'), which widens runtime activity and resource usage—this is expected for an autonomous loop tool but worth noting before granting full autonomy.

Install Mechanism

No install specification is provided (instruction-only plus a small bash helper script). Nothing is downloaded or written by an installer step beyond normal use of loop.sh and editing project files. This is the lowest-risk install posture.

Credentials

The skill declares no required environment variables, credentials, or config paths. The SKILL.md references running standard project commands (npm, pytest, mypy, etc.) but does not request secrets. This is proportionate to a coordination/methodology skill. Note: to actually push commits, run CI, or access cloud resources in real workflows a user would need to grant external credentials outside this skill—those are not requested by the skill itself.

Persistence & Privilege

always:false and no install means this skill does not demand permanent forced inclusion. However, the runtime instructions expect the platform to spawn sub-agents and permit committing changes and running arbitrary repo commands. If you enable autonomous invocation for your agent, the skill will exercise those abilities; that is consistent with its purpose but increases the scope of actions the agent can perform on your repository and build environment.

Assessment

This skill appears coherent and does not request secrets or install arbitrary code, but it coordinates broad repository operations: it will read project files, run build/test/typecheck/lint commands, and instruct sub-agents to implement and commit changes. Before using it: (1) run it in a sandbox or branch first so commits and commands cannot affect production; (2) review AGENTS.md and IMPLEMENTATION_PLAN.md to ensure validation commands are safe and non-destructive; (3) restrict autonomous invocation if you don't want the agent to spawn many sub-agents or make commits without manual approval; and (4) do not grant repository, CI, cloud, or GPU credentials unless you explicitly trust the workflow and have audited the commands it will run.

Ralph Mode implements the Ralph Wiggum technique adapted for OpenClaw: autonomous task completion through continuous iteration with backpressure gates, completion criteria, and structured planning.

When to Use

Use Ralph Mode when:

• Building features that require multiple iterations and refinement
• Working on complex projects with acceptance criteria to validate
• Need automated testing, linting, or typecheck gates
• Want to track progress across many iterations systematically
• Prefer autonomous loops over manual turn-by-turn guidance

Core Principles

Three-Phase Workflow

Phase 1: Requirements Definition

• Document specs in specs/ (one file per topic of concern)
• Define acceptance criteria (observable, verifiable outcomes)
• Create implementation plan with prioritized tasks

Phase 2: Planning

• Gap analysis: compare specs against existing code
• Generate IMPLEMENTATION_PLAN.md with prioritized tasks
• No implementation during this phase

Phase 3: Building (Iterative)

• Pick one task from plan per iteration
• Implement, validate, update plan, commit
• Continue until all tasks complete or criteria met

Backpressure Gates

Reject incomplete work automatically through validation:

Programmatic Gates (Always use these):

• Tests: [test command] - Must pass before committing
• Typecheck: [typecheck command] - Catch type errors early
• Lint: [lint command] - Enforce code quality
• Build: [build command] - Verify integration

Subjective Gates (Use for UX, design, quality):

• LLM-as-judge reviews for tone, aesthetics, usability
• Binary pass/fail - converges through iteration
• Only add after programmatic gates work reliably

Context Efficiency

• One task per iteration = fresh context each time
• Spawn sub-agents for exploration, not main context
• Lean prompts = smart zone (~40-60% utilization)
• Plans are disposable - regenerate cheap vs. salvage

File Structure

Create this structure for each Ralph Mode project:

project-root/
├── IMPLEMENTATION_PLAN.md     # Shared state, updated each iteration
├── AGENTS.md                  # Build/test/lint commands (~60 lines)
├── specs/                     # Requirements (one file per topic)
│   ├── topic-a.md
│   └── topic-b.md
├── src/                        # Application code
└── src/lib/                    # Shared utilities

IMPLEMENTATION_PLAN.md

Priority task list - single source of truth. Format:

# Implementation Plan

## In Progress
- [ ] Task name (iteration N)
  - Notes: discoveries, bugs, blockers

## Completed
- [x] Task name (iteration N)

## Backlog
- [ ] Future task

Topic Scope Test

Can you describe the topic in one sentence without "and"?

• ✅ "User authentication with JWT and session management"
• ❌ "Auth, profiles, and billing" → 3 topics

AGENTS.md - Operational Guide

Succinct guide for running the project. Keep under 60 lines:

# Project Operations

## Build Commands
npm run dev      # Development server
npm run build     # Production build

## Validation
npm run test      # All tests
npm run lint      # ESLint
npm run typecheck  # TypeScript
npm run e2e       # E2E tests

## Operational Notes
- Tests must pass before committing
- Typecheck failures block commits
- Use existing utilities from src/lib over ad-hoc copies

Hats (Personas)

Specialized roles for different tasks:

Hat: Architect (@architect)

• High-level design, data modeling, API contracts
• Focus: patterns, scalability, maintainability

Hat: Implementer (@implementer)

• Write code, implement features, fix bugs
• Focus: correctness, performance, test coverage

Hat: Tester (@tester)

• Test authoring, validation, edge cases
• Focus: coverage, reliability, reproducibility

Hat: Reviewer (@reviewer)

• Code reviews, PR feedback, quality assessment
• Focus: style, readability, adherence to specs

Usage:

"Spawn a sub-agent with @architect hat to design the data model"

Loop Mechanics

Outer Loop (You coordinate)

Your job as main agent: engineer setup, observe, course-correct.

1. Don't allocate work to main context - Spawn sub-agents
2. Let Ralph Ralph - LLM will self-identify, self-correct
3. Use protection - Sandbox is your security boundary
4. Plan is disposable - Regenerate when wrong/stale
5. Move outside the loop - Sit and watch, don't micromanage

Inner Loop (Sub-agent executes)

Each sub-agent iteration:

1. Study - Read plan, specs, relevant code
2. Select - Pick most important uncompleted task
3. Implement - Write code, one task only
4. Validate - Run tests, lint, typecheck (backpressure)
5. Update - Mark task done, note discoveries, commit
6. Exit - Next iteration starts fresh

Stopping Conditions

Loop ends when:

• ✅ All IMPLEMENTATION_PLAN.md tasks completed
• ✅ All acceptance criteria met
• ✅ Tests passing, no blocking issues
• ⚠️ Max iterations reached (configure limit)
• 🛑 Manual stop (Ctrl+C)

Completion Criteria

Define success upfront - avoid "seems done" ambiguity.

Programmatic (Measurable)

• All tests pass: [test_command] returns 0
• Typecheck passes: No TypeScript errors
• Build succeeds: Production bundle created
• Coverage threshold: e.g., 80%+

Subjective (LLM-as-Judge)

For quality criteria that resist automation:

## Completion Check - UX Quality
Criteria: Navigation is intuitive, primary actions are discoverable
Test: User can complete core flow without confusion

## Completion Check - Design Quality
Criteria: Visual hierarchy is clear, brand consistency maintained
Test: Layout follows established patterns

Run LLM-as-judge sub-agent for binary pass/fail.

Technology-Specific Patterns

Next.js Full Stack

specs/
├── authentication.md
├── database.md
└── api-routes.md

src/
├── app/                    # App Router
├── components/              # React components
├── lib/                    # Utilities (db, auth, helpers)
└── types/                   # TypeScript types

AGENTS.md:
  Build: npm run dev
  Test: npm run test
  Typecheck: npx tsc --noEmit
  Lint: npm run lint

Python (Scripts/Notebooks/FastAPI)

specs/
├── data-pipeline.md
├── model-training.md
└── api-endpoints.md

src/
├── pipeline.py
├── models/
├── api/
└── tests/

AGENTS.md:
  Build: python -m src.main
  Test: pytest
  Typecheck: mypy src/
  Lint: ruff check src/

GPU Workloads

specs/
├── model-architecture.md
├── training-data.md
└── inference-pipeline.md

src/
├── models/
├── training/
├── inference/
└── utils/

AGENTS.md:
  Train: python train.py
  Test: pytest tests/
  Lint: ruff check src/
  GPU Check: nvidia-smi

Quick Start Command

Start a Ralph Mode session:

"Start Ralph Mode for my project at ~/projects/my-app. I want to implement user authentication with JWT.

I will:

1. Create IMPLEMENTATION_PLAN.md with prioritized tasks
2. Spawn sub-agents for iterative implementation
3. Apply backpressure gates (test, lint, typecheck)
4. Track progress and announce completion

Operational Learnings

When Ralph patterns emerge, update AGENTS.md:

## Discovered Patterns

- When adding API routes, also add to OpenAPI spec
- Use existing db utilities from src/lib/db over direct calls
- Test files must be co-located with implementation

Escape Hatches

When trajectory goes wrong:

• Ctrl+C - Stop loop immediately
• Regenerate plan - "Discard IMPLEMENTATION_PLAN.md and re-plan"
• Reset - "Git reset to last known good state"
• Scope down - Create smaller scoped plan for specific work

Advanced: LLM-as-Judge Fixture

For subjective criteria (tone, aesthetics, UX):

Create src/lib/llm-review.ts:

interface ReviewResult {
  pass: boolean;
  feedback?: string;
}

async function createReview(config: {
  criteria: string;
  artifact: string; // text or screenshot path
}): Promise<ReviewResult>;

Sub-agents discover and use this pattern for binary pass/fail checks.

Critical Operational Requirements

Based on empirical usage, enforce these practices to avoid silent failures:

1. Mandatory Progress Logging

Ralph MUST write to PROGRESS.md after EVERY iteration. This is non-negotiable.

Create PROGRESS.md in project root at start:

# Ralph: [Task Name]

## Iteration [N] - [Timestamp]

### Status
- [ ] In Progress | [ ] Blocked | [ ] Complete

### What Was Done
- [Item 1]
- [Item 2]

### Blockers
- None | [Description]

### Next Step
[Specific next task from IMPLEMENTATION_PLAN.md]

### Files Changed
- `path/to/file.ts` - [brief description]

Why: External observers (parent agents, crons, humans) can tail one file instead of scanning directories or inferring state from session logs.

2. Session Isolation & Cleanup

Before spawning a new Ralph session:

• Check for existing Ralph sub-agents via sessions_list
• Kill or verify completion of previous sessions
• Do NOT spawn overlapping Ralph sessions on same codebase

Anti-pattern: Spawning Ralph v2 while v1 is still running = file conflicts, race conditions, lost work.

3. Explicit Path Verification

Never assume directory structure. At start of each iteration:

// Verify current working directory
const cwd = process.cwd();
console.log(`Working in: ${cwd}`);

// Verify expected paths exist
if (!fs.existsSync('./src/app')) {
  console.error('Expected ./src/app, found:', fs.readdirSync('.'));
  // Adapt or fail explicitly
}

Why: Ralph may be spawned from different contexts with different working directories.

4. Completion Signal Protocol

When done, Ralph MUST:

1. Write final PROGRESS.md with "## Status: COMPLETE"
2. List all created/modified files
3. Exit cleanly (no hanging processes)

Example completion PROGRESS.md:

# Ralph: Influencer Detail Page

## Status: COMPLETE ✅

**Finished:** [ISO timestamp]

### Final Verification
- [x] TypeScript: Pass
- [x] Tests: Pass  
- [x] Build: Pass

### Files Created
- `src/app/feature/page.tsx`
- `src/app/api/feature/route.ts`

### Testing Instructions
1. Run: `npm run dev`
2. Visit: `http://localhost:3000/feature`
3. Verify: [specific checks]

5. Error Handling Requirements

If Ralph encounters unrecoverable errors:

1. Log to PROGRESS.md with "## Status: BLOCKED"
2. Describe blocker in detail
3. List attempted solutions
4. Exit cleanly (don't hang)

Do not silently fail. A Ralph that stops iterating with no progress log is indistinguishable from one still working.

6. Iteration Time Limits

Set explicit iteration timeouts:

## Operational Parameters
- Max iteration time: 10 minutes
- Total session timeout: 60 minutes
- If iteration exceeds limit: Log blocker, exit

Why: Prevents infinite loops on stuck tasks, allows parent agent to intervene.

Memory Updates

After each Ralph Mode session, document:

## [Date] Ralph Mode Session

**Project:** [project-name]
**Duration:** [iterations]
**Outcome:** success / partial / blocked
**Learnings:**
- What worked well
- What needs adjustment
- Patterns to add to AGENTS.md

Appendix: Hall of Failures

Common anti-patterns observed:

Anti-Pattern	Consequence	Prevention
No progress logging	Parent agent cannot determine status	Mandatory PROGRESS.md
Silent failure	Work lost, time wasted	Explicit error logging
Overlapping sessions	File conflicts, corrupt state	Check/cleanup before spawn
Path assumptions	Wrong directory, wrong files	Explicit verification
No completion signal	Parent waits indefinitely	Clear COMPLETE status
Infinite iteration	Resource waste, no progress	Time limits + blockers
Complex initial prompts	Sub-agent never starts (empty session logs)	SIMPLIFY instructions

NEW: Session Initialization Best Practices (2025-02-07)

Problem: Sub-agents spawn but don't execute

Evidence: Empty session logs (2 bytes), no tool calls, 0 tokens used

Root Causes

1. Instructions too complex - Overwhelms isolated session initialization
2. No clear execution trigger - Agent doesn't know to start
3. Branching logic - "If X do Y, if Z do W" confuses task selection
4. Multiple files mentioned - Can't decide which to start with

Fix: SIMPLIFIED Ralph Task Template

## Task: [ONE specific thing]

**File:** exact/path/to/file.ts
**What:** Exact description of change
**Validate:** Exact command to run
**Then:** Update PROGRESS.md and exit

## Rules
1. Do NOT look at other files
2. Do NOT "check first"
3. Make the change, validate, exit

BEFORE (Bad - causes stalls):

Fix all TypeScript errors across these files:
- lib/db.ts has 2 errors
- lib/proposal-service.ts has 5 errors
- route.ts has errors
Check which ones to fix first, then...

AFTER (Good - executes):

Fix lib/db.ts line 27:
Change: PoolClient to pg.PoolClient
Validate: npm run typecheck
Exit immediately after

CRITICAL: Single File Rule

Each Ralph iteration gets ONE file. Not "all errors", not "check then decide". ONE file, ONE change, validate, exit.

CRITICAL: Update PROGRESS.md

MANDATORY: After EVERY iteration, update PROGRESS.md with:

## Iteration [N] - [Timestamp]

### Status: Complete ✅ | Blocked ⛔ | Failed ❌

### What Was Done
- [Specific changes made]

### Validation
- [Test/lint/typecheck results]

### Next Step
- [What should happen next]

Why this matters: Cron job reads PROGRESS.md for status updates. If not updated, status appears stale/repetitive.

Debugging Ralph Stalls

If Ralph stalls:

1. Check session logs (should show tool calls within 60s)
2. If empty after spawn → instructions too complex
3. Reduce: ONE file, ONE line number, ONE change
4. Shorter timeout forces smaller tasks (300s not 600s)

Fixing Stale Status Reports

If cron reports same status repeatedly:

1. Check PROGRESS.md was updated by sub-agent
2. If not updated → sub-agent skipped documentation step
3. Update skill: Add "MANDATORY PROGRESS.md update" to prompt
4. Manual fix: Update PROGRESS.md to reflect actual state

Summary

Ralph works when: Single file focus + explicit change + validate + exit Ralph stalls when: Complex decisions + multiple files + conditional logic